Solid Surface Countertops

What They Are

Manufactured from acrylic or polyester resins mixed with mineral fillers, formed into sheets. Brands include Corian, Hi-Macs, and Koris.

Pros

• Seamless appearance: Joints can be chemically bonded to become nearly invisible

• Repairable: Scratches and minor burns can be sanded out

• Non-porous: Resists stains and doesn't require sealing

• Consistent appearance: Uniform color and pattern throughout

• Integrated designs: Sinks and backsplashes can be seamlessly integrated

• Wide variety: Available in many colors and patterns (including stone-like designs)

• Moderate cost: Generally less expensive than granite

Cons

• Vulnerable to heat: Can be damaged by hot pans (use trivets recommended)

• Can scratch: Softer surface than stone (though repairable)

• Less "natural" look: May not have the authentic appearance of real stone

• Moderate durability: Can be damaged by sharp impacts

Granite Countertops

What They Are

Natural stone quarried from the earth, cut into slabs, polished, and installed.

Pros

• Natural beauty: Unique veining and patterns, no two slabs are identical

• Heat resistant: Can withstand hot pans (though sudden temperature changes can cause cracking)

• Very durable: Resists scratches and chips better than solid surface

• Adds home value: Often preferred by home buyers

• Long-lasting: Can last a lifetime with proper care

Cons

• Porous: Requires regular sealing (typically annually) to prevent staining

• Seams visible: Joints between slabs are more noticeable

• Limited repairability: Deep chips or cracks are difficult to fix

• Higher cost: More expensive than solid surface

• Weight: Requires sturdy cabinet support

• Natural variations: Color/pattern may differ from sample

Head-to-Head Comparison

Best Applications

Choose Solid Surface If:

• You want a seamless, modern look

• You prefer low maintenance (no sealing)

• You need integrated sinks or custom shapes

• Budget is a consideration

• You like consistent patterns and colors

• Repairability is important

Choose Granite If:

• You value natural stone aesthetics

• Heat resistance is a priority

• You're looking to increase home resale value

• You don't mind periodic maintenance

• You want maximum durability against scratches

• Budget allows for higher investment

Care & Maintenance

Solid Surface:

• Clean with mild soap and water

• Remove stains with gentle abrasive cleaner

• Use cutting boards and trivets

• Sand out minor scratches

Granite:

• Clean with pH-balanced stone cleaner

• Seal annually (or as recommended)

• Wipe spills promptly, especially acidic substances

• Use cutting boards to protect finish

Cost Considerations

• Solid Surface: $50-$150 per square foot installed

• Granite: $60-$200+ per square foot installed

• Both prices vary by region, material quality, edge details, and installation complexity

Trends & Innovations

• Solid surface: New patterns mimic natural stone more convincingly

• Granite: Finishes beyond polished (leathered, honed) are growing in popularity

• Both materials now available in thinner, lighter versions

Final Thought

Both solid surface and granite are excellent countertop materials. Your final decision should be based on your lifestyle, design vision, and budget. Visit local showrooms to touch and see full slabs in person. Bring samples home to view in your space's lighting. For a balance of durability and aesthetics, also consider exploring quartz countertops, which offer a third compelling option.

FAQ: Solid Surface vs. Granite

Q: Which is more expensive, solid surface or granite?
A: Typically, granite is more expensive, but high-end solid surface materials can rival the price of mid-range granite.

Q: Can you put hot pans on solid surface?
A: No. You should always use a trivet or hot pad on solid surface countertops to prevent thermal damage.

Q: Does granite stain easily?
A: Not if it is properly and regularly sealed. A well-maintained granite countertop is highly stain-resistant.

Q: Which is better for a bathroom vanity?
A: Both work well. Solid surface allows for integrated sink bowls. Granite offers a classic, spa-like luxury. Consider moisture and your maintenance preference.

solid surface

acrylic solid surface

corian solid surface